buy lithium chloride uk what is himalaya himcolin gel can i order buspar no prescription in the usa levothroid spain over counter finax from india sominex looking for legit online meds buying baby alligators doxycycline hyclate (vibra-tabs) 100mg oral tab betnovate skin cream review buy finast astrailia liv 52 usage do i need a prescription for vermox visa pamelor cause weight gain chloroquine reviews and dosage paypal pay by check amantadine pharmacy alli sales figures buy actonel from india buy micronase 40 can order famvir canada wellbutrin sr to buy in australia is it safe to order naprosyn buying cephalexin using paypal donde comprar lexapro no rx furosemide online levlen contraceptive pill pregnancy genuine viagra sublingual 100mg kamagra gold 100mg purchase cheap generic famvir hydrochlorothiazide uk buy no script minipress mg zebeta uk buy atacand medication assistance indian generics online epivir-hbv what effect does kamagra have on women comprar finax online buy clonidine non prescription glycomet tablets us online kamagra oral jelly tablets 40mg meclizine max daily dose tazorac vs retin a wrinkles buy plavix from canada side effects of sildenafil citrate 50mg lexapro canadian pharmacy zyprexa generic cost seroquel xr 300 mg prices augmentin 500-125 can i take 30mg of cialis cheap generic viagra 25mg nombre generico de celebrex what does differin gel do is mail order zyprexa safe wikipedia de levitra plus haldol generic drug acivir pills on line no script cheap erythromycin 500mg buy generic arimidex online no prescription flonase 100mg cheep non generic celebrex generic elocon safe purchase aciphex purchase canadian pharmacy quiero comprar doxycycline cefixime order luvox pills online in the mexico liv tablets for purchase buy wellbutrin in canada free online birth control presription mentax side effects long term use adjusting to higher synthroid dose what does remeron do walmart $10 drug list minocin billig kaufen best place to buy colchicine in mexico alesse side effects uk pain meds for dogs after neutering prednisolone for dogs for sale uk buy luvox online from mexico what is eurax hydrocortisone cream order ponstel tablets canadian hospital pharmacy residency board anyone bought clomid online uk can you buy brand levitra in ireland original minocycline online lilly usa cymbalta nike 95 trainers for sale how do i get viagra how to take fertomid 100mg where can i get triamterene pills cloridrato de sertralina ajuda a emagrecer buy levitra with dapoxetine ajanta pharma wiki can order menosan online order viagra from mexican pharmacy valsartan and hydrochlorothiazide generic lisinopril brand names in india what is the dose for haldol xanax generic pill identifier canada drugs coumadin with prescription nexium 40 mg tablet nedir low dose of viagra cheap ampicillin mg how to take triamterene hctz best place buy clomid amaryl order online ginette-35 pill shortage rx express pharmacy grove city cefixime buy online uk where to buy amaryllis many cleocin gel maximum dosage nexium for dogs buy viagra effects interactions can you take cipro flagyl together take nizoral pills snafi 20 mg tablets cleocin canada prescription very cheap revatio acai 100mg cheap generic viagra price per pill comprar actonel original bupropion hydrochloride rxlist nootropil uses medication penegra pharmacy how old do you have to be to get a viagra prescription vardenafil pharmacy comprar propranolol zyban drugs online purchases ordering diflucan on line buy cleocin online reviews where can i buy synthroid prix du xenical en pharmacie free trial cialis voucher buy cardura capsules cipralex side effects headache extendaquin results forum khawaja naveed ki adalat november 2013 where to buy metformin 500 glucotrol xl over the counter where do i revatio in canada lamictal cost australia buy cheap levitra professional buy hyzaar 80 mg online zithromax canada buy what is the mode of action for ampicillin levitra cialis viagra side effects aricept shortage 2012 does finpecia work cialis e-shops europe neurontin side effects weight gain hytrin price buy caverta for daily use abana express canada disfuncion erectil sintomas y causas comprar viagra online portugal how to take albendazole propecia over counter urispas australia pharmacy coumadin prescription warning buspar prescription price what is indinavir buy wellbutrin what is imitrex medication forum prescription order zyrtec online buspar 100 xenical and meridia together is mail order stromectol safe bentyl pills sweat montelukast singulair 4mg buy ortho tri-cyclen lo uk purim delivery london benadryl with paypal payment genuine celexa 100mg cost of zyrtec d what is better levitra or viagra is rizatriptan the same as maxalt online generic revia how to purchase lipitor online liquid cephalexin shelf life tetracycline fish discount vermox online click here prescription medicine for lower back pain ciplox drugs online purchases cipro cheap mexico pharmacy lexapro next day delivery carafate ships from india allegra compared to zyrtec get promethazine codeine over counter zovirax ointment 5 uses ceftin discount buy genuine levitra professional uk best us pharmacy prices online pharmacy uk voveran sr cipla india suhagra 100 ultra low dose kytril where can i buy haldol mg there generic erythromycin where can i purchase viagra is generic cialis available in canada wahl lithium ion costco lasix water pill potassium cam you order allegra canada pulmicort ulotka maxalt dose children voltaren for sale australia online forum buy order astelin buy propranolol paypal accepted dramamine on line evista canada drug store generic paroxetine usa pharmacy bentyl where can i buy it cost of cialis without insurance lozol ordering online pharmacy lamictal 10 mg prescription solutions mail order pharmacy coming down off effexor xr tdi trimix ccr printable medrol dose pack instructions comprar synthroid en argentina buy kamagra using paypal uk can u get high off of indomethacin diltiazem mr tablets lexapro no prescription cheap price online pharmacy generic and trade name for lipitor buy doxycycline fast shipping colchicine uk brand name genesis acai 100 review cleocin gel dosage recommended cheap motrin sale uk mail order trandate online professional store pharmacy cheap viagra spc lisinopril tablets purchase generic calcium carbonate lidocaine ointment donde puedo comprar diltiazem cozaar dosage high blood pressure acheter hoodia au maroc coreg on the internet what is the dosage for valtrex for herpes clomid side effects in men consecuencias de tomar cytotec para abortar reviews on cardura full practice guidance otc tamsulosin lozol online store buy generic dutasteride 2.5mg bystolic paypal food network live in italian 1 guy 1 jar yahoo answers indocin online from usa caverta doctors online search twitter by location super cissus rx coumadin azithromycin tablets 250 mg purchase advair lowest price can you get high off nexium 40mg effexor xr generic australia can you only get suhagra on prescription cephalexin online buy kamagra gel wiki what is ophthacare used for arimidex for sale in the philippines generic parlodel cost para que sirve el lexapro 10 mg overnight delivery buy propecia lady era maximum dosage rhinocort aqua drug classification buy betoptic mg online cialis professional ships from india moduretic tablet side effects clarithromycin side effects insomnia rocaltrol to buy from europe what is the medicine zyprexa for buy cozaar mg augmentin in india mg colospa without prescription arimidex generic uk does cephalexin make you gain weight speman mail order plavix reviews cialis tablets for sale indian aciphex buy generic is finax available over the counter buy cytotec no prescription online lipothin suppliers overseas cardizem prescription only lopressor hct novartis trazodone medication insomnia what is casodex used to treat voltaren tablets for lower back pain doxycycline no prescription canada clomid and alcohol interaction how can i get lexapro cheaper best place to buy shatavari secure pharmacy shopping mail order zyban what is the dosage for cymbalta elocon overnight shipping cheap clomiphene challenge how to take ginseng powder claravis better than accutane generic zerit us buy arimidex online thru paypals lasuna mail order cystone prices usa where to purchase benadryl d can you buy methotrexate in ireland hydrochlorothiazide for sale online indian pharmacy prinivil albendazole oral suspension india generic pills for femara liv 52 coupon code purchase adalat 6 pharmacy where to buy cheap generic crestor how to get desyrel on line antabuse delivered to your home furosemide precio mexico yasmin boland scorpio prednisone 10mg tablet 2g azithromycin side effects 10mg buy amitriptyline online can buy alli canada danazol italiano prescription price buy accutane online skelaxin 800 mg coupons generic aldactone no prescription benzac online pay paypal where to get zantac for babies buy tramadol overnight delivery no prescription aceon 40 mg pharmacy cane you buy diflucan otc very cheap ciplox brand cialis without prescription colchicine free shipping unisom overdose side effects buy silagra with paypal buy viagra plus hong kong amantadine company terbutaline side effects pregnancy resources for viagra plus what is albenza used for uloric vs allopurinol cost diclofenac sodium 50 mg tablets side effects how long to use finpecia maximum dosage for cialis buy generic amantadine what is amantadine tablets generic actoplus metformin buy non prescription erexin-v pharmacy can you viagra soft in ireland buy uk canadian pharmacy is 40mg of levitra too much zyprexa reviews depression temporal arteritis prednisone dosage is there a shortage of innopran valtrex 1000 mg 21 tablet fiyat? cialis piu economico atacand prescription buy compazine hong kong prescription generic terramycin mail order betnovate online no prescription lowest priced omnicef norvasc order online no prescription where to buy viagra over the counter in usa pharmacy purchase cialis super active mg canada drugs pharmacy reviews what does allegra antihistamine fexofenadine betoptic where to get how long does it take pyridium to start working sinemet looking for best erection pills uk india cardizem price over counter endep proventil shop what is celexa used for arimidex spain best place to buy generic levitra purchase medrol online no prescription where to purchase brahmi arimidex to buy from europe Purchase abilify online no rx pharmacy current price terramycin viagra plus sale prescription where can your buy valtrex united pharmacy dutas generic viagra jelly switzerland atarax 10 mg tabletas para que sirve tower pharmacy amsterdam ny penegra price albenza dosage worms can order meclizine canada aspirin 100 mg ec tablets toprol xl drug oversea is canadian health and care mall legit famvir tablets online benzac delivery uk buy risperdal generic female cialis usa pharmacy use keflex coupon online diamox by mail non generic amitriptyline buy cardizem online with out prescription fertomid medicine children is it legal to sell kamagra in the uk generic name for advair diskus 500 50 benicar generic 2013 buy elavil overseas lotensin rxlist generic for actoplus metformin pioglitazone where to buy lithium where to buy acai berry puree buy coumadin without a subscription where to buy genuine cialis lamictal capsules where to buy zanaflex with mastercard can you buy viagra mexico billig allopurinol online kaufen how much is bactroban without insurance tricor weight gain actos medication overnight delivery acne medicine accutane on trial entocort ec prices buy pravachol lowest price alphagan order in the us lowest priced proventil ayurslim online coupon code where can i buy female viagra the drugstore cowboys seroquel discounted cardizem mail order india where can i get voveran sr what is differin cream for cefadroxil daily use reviews walmart $4 generic drug list 2012 purchase rosuvastatin online can you buy cialis sublingual in ireland 20mg uk online drug generic wellbutrin sr uk gasex order in the us para que serve a substancia citrato de sildenafila buy albuterol inhaler online can order female viagra online genesis today acai vitamin super chews reviews nizoral tablets purchase on line buying zetia clarithromycin in pregnancy what does keppra interact with torsemide dose equivalent furosemide buying mevacor in manchester natural anxiety medication reviews study master in pharmacy in canada generic for avapro 300 mg tegretol max dose buying alli online uk nolvadex sale uk galaxy lithium mine ravensthorpe western australia adalat sony tv 24 feb 2013 rumalaya liniment online in us maxalt headache medicine abana non perscription countries metformin brand positioning gyne-lotrimin prices can you only get extendaquin on prescription donde comprar dutasteride generic for zovirax cream pariet pill shortage sale risperdal buy levitra online with prescription brand bystolic buy himcocid dosage too high amitriptyline indian brands generic form of sarafem entocort sublingual dosage retin a canada no prescription western drug chloromycetin cost of levothroid without insurance farmacia line comprar brand levitra cheap yasmin buy online how to order lasuna online ranitidine sale non prescription allopurinol ultra low dose fincar buy omnicef hong kong how much is generic zoloft coreg uk buy what is cephalexin mg used to treat get aldactone las vegas lansoprazole dose bnf cholestoplex without insurance buy levaquin online india no prescription buy renagel online india how to make promethazine codeine cough syrup torsemide price discount keflex mg what are the side effects of the depo provera birth control shot low price brand levitra uk cialis super active buy canada caverta in the uk legal buy pilex online canada tricor now flomax to purchase without a prescription generic proventil for sale on line canada meds without rx how long does it take for strattera to become effective
"Let not your heart be troubled; believe in God, believe also in me" John 14:1
Home arrow Modern Issues arrow Capital Punishment arrow TENNESSEE'S DEATH PENALTY MORATORIUM
TENNESSEE'S DEATH PENALTY MORATORIUM Print E-mail
Written by Kevin L. Howard   
Are death penalty moratoriums a good thing?  David Gushee, in a February 2007 article (http://countercultureblog.com), argues that Tennessee Governor Phil Bredesen's temporary suspension of all executions is indeed a good move.  In fact, Gushee wants a longer moratorium in Tennessee and nationwide.

 

Gushee says, "When the Supreme Court ruled in 1976 that states could resume executions, they mandated that any state doing so must apply this ultimate penalty in a fair and consistent, rather than arbitrary and capricious, manner."  Certainly, if a state can make the process better, they should.  But is a long moratorium the only answer?

 

Gushee claims, "Tennessee's death penalty sentencing is rife with error.  Half of all death sentences in our state are overturned on appeal due to serious constitutional error, according to a study by The Tennessean."  But overturned cases don't mean these prisoners were innocent.  And Gushee's statement, "That number does not include those sitting on death row who are, in all likelihood, innocent of the crimes for which they were convicted," assumes, without much basis, their innocence.

 

Innocent People

If people like Paul House are truly innocent, then they should be released.  But if his case is so open and shut, why is he still in prison?  DNA testing, often used as an argument against capital punishment, can make cases like House's easier to deal with, not establish a reason to stop executions.

 

While some innocent people probably do get caught in the system, the risk is worth the injustice of the guilty living on death row for 20-plus years.  Besides, the innocents who die at the hand of those still on death row are probably far more numerous than those innocent people actually on death row.  (See two articles by Dennis Prager: Capital Punishment -- Another Argument For It and George Will and Capital Punishment.)

 

Race and Economics

Gushee then brings up the race issue by saying, "National studies repeatedly find both race-of-perpetrator and race-of-victim bias in death penalty sentencing.  In Tennessee, racial/ethnic minorities are vastly overrepresented on death row, and a full quarter of African Americans on Tennessee's death row were sentenced by all-white juries."  The issue is never, how many blacks versus whites are on death row, or how many whites versus Hispanics.  The question is, who commits more death-row-deserving crimes?  If the statistics show that blacks commit more heinous crimes than whites, then there should be more blacks than whites on death row.  And is it really that hard to make sure cases don't end up with all-white juries? 

 

Not all studies confirm the often used racist theory: "A 1991 Rand Corporation study by Stephen Klein found that white murderers received the death penalty slightly more often (32%) than non-white murderers (27%).  And while the study found murderers of white victims received the death penalty more often (32%) than murderers of non-white victims (23%), when controlled for variables such as severity and number of crimes committed, there is no disparity between those sentenced to death for killing white or black victims" (Wesley Lowe).

 

Gushee moves on to social and economic inequities, "In Tennessee, nearly every one of the 102 people on death row could not afford an attorney at trial."  Can Tennessee provide better public defenders?  If so, this would solve many of their problems.

 

Logical Thinking

We need to think clearly, as Gushee cautions, "It is not logical to respond to this evidence by affirming one's visceral support for the principle of life-for-life."  But the assumption to stop an already slow moving system isn't the answer to justice. 

 

He continues, "Would not such a passion for justice also require the fair application of this penalty?"  So why can't Tennessee, in the spirit of equal opportunity, start executing all people on death row?  The state could even give everyone on death row a two-year heads up.  Anyone still on death row after two years would be executed promptly according to a fast moving system that started with all white male prisoners.

 

Insanity

Then Gushee pulls out the old insanity argument to mount sympathy for his case: "Would we also want to be sure that the people we are executing are morally responsible for their actions, rather than clinically insane, as are a number of our death row inmates?"  Should we always assume that everyone classified as insane needs to escape the death penalty?  Even if the answer ends up being yes, this problem could be solved by testing and then putting those who qualify in asylums.  (I wonder how many death row inmates would love the opportunity to test, or shall we say, audition?)

 

Inconsistent System

If Gushee is right in his statement, "Nationally, and in this state, the application of the death penalty is about as rational and orderly as who wins the lottery," surely a bit of ingenuity could be pulled off the shelf to make the system rational and orderly.  (See previous paragraphs.)

 

He admits that, "In the end, a small percentage of convicted murderers get the death penalty, and an even smaller group is actually executed."  But he uses this fact to point out the supposed randomness and inconsistencies of executions.  According to Gushee's admission, we're not talking about a fast moving conveyor belt in a slaughter house.  As best as I can tell, Tennessee has only executed a little more than 130 people since 1909.  It's a slow moving process, like the brain cells of Al Gore trying to think of something other than global warming.  So make the system more consistent, as I suggested above, but don't stop executions long term to do it.

 

DNA

Gushee then stands on the shoulders of DNA and asks, "How many innocent executed persons is too many?"  We obviously don't want to kill innocent people.  That's why we should work for a better justice system, rather than disable it altogether.  A little more than 1,000 people have been executed since 1976 in the United States, so again, we're not talking about a large number, let alone a plethora of innocent people.  My question is, how many innocent people die as a result of letting so many guilty live?  (Again, see Prager's articles.)

 

Fair Systems and the Bible

By referring to Deuteronomy 17:6, Gushee hopes to show how unfair our justice system is today.  But the point of the eyewitnesses in the Old Testament is overwhelming evidence to convict.  Our justice system requires evidence beyond a reasonable doubt.  So our system is fair.  Gushee refers to the New Testament's focus of mercy in hopes of persuading readers to his view.  But his passing comments on mercy could mislead.  Mercy can also be shown to the majority of citizen by making sure that true perpetrators of vicious crimes die swiftly for their acts, rather than outlive their victims' family members.  And let's not forget what the New Testament says about a government's role in justice.  Was the Roman justice system always fair?  (I can think of at least one famous innocent person who died at its hand.)  Yet, in Romans 13, God approved of governments carrying out capital punishment.

 

Conclusion

Gushee's goal is noble-a fair justice system.  I commend him for this aim.  But his call for a prolonged moratorium on executions is the wrong approach.  If Tennessee's system is unfair, it can be corrected without a long moratorium.  And when it's improved, it can be cranked up to breakneck speed-in the name of true justice ( See Ecclesiastes 8:11).

 

May the people of Tennessee review their current justice system and improve it, if need be.  But hopefully this act will not be another liberal move that uses a moratorium as a knife plunged in the back of Lady Justice.

 

 

For articles on why Christians should support capital punishment, click here

 
< Prev   Next >
 

 

Home    Site Map    About NNF    Search    Contact Us    Statement of Faith

 

Theology and pop culture from a conservative evangelical perspective.

 
Joomla Template design by RocketTheme